To the Editor:
“Radicalism Among Muslim Professionals Worry [sic] Many” (news article, July 14) offers many plausible reasons why physicians—trained as healers—sometimes become fanatical killers.
None strike as deep, however, as the psychiatrist Robert J. Lifton’s “healing-killing paradox.” Dr. Lifton explained how Nazi doctors convinced themselves that they were “killing Jews in order to heal the Nordic race.”
By so conjoining acts of murder with a function traditionally performed by physicians, these doctors were able to do the unthinkable.
I suspect that we shall eventually discover a similarly twisted paradox beneath the actions of the more recent physician terrorists.
Ronald Pies, M.D.
Lexington, Mass., July 14, 2007
The writer is a professor of psychiatry at State University of New York Upstate Medical University.
Note from KBJ: Why is everyone puzzled by the fact that doctors kill? I’m not the least bit puzzled by it. Doctors are highly trained, efficient, enthusiastic killers. Every day, they do their damnedest to destroy bacteria, viruses, germs, and tumors. How many fetuses are killed every day by otherwise normal physicians? Think of it this way: In order for an organism to live, other organisms must die. If the task of medicine is to promote life, then doctors not only may, but must, be killers. I’ll leave the rest of the explanation to you.
Note 2 from KBJ: I got a kick out of the following sentence from the New York Times story:
The whole purpose of science for some Islamists is using it to reinforce faith; it really has nothing to do with science itself.
Replace “Islamists” with “progressives” and the statement remains true. Think of all the questions that progressives refuse to ask, for fear that they will not like the answers: questions about innate sex differences, about racial differences, about intelligence, about the etiology of homosexuality, and so forth. When progressives accuse conservatives of letting ideology trump science, they know whereof they speak!