Keith:
On the question of whether Yankee fans want Rodriguez back, I can only speak for myself. The answer is yes, albeit with some reservations.
Without him, the team loses more than 25 per cent of its home run production and around a 6th or seventh of its total RBI production. Plus he is a good fielder, good base runner, good base stealer.
It’s true the Yankees need serious starting pitching to be a potential winner. But they also need runs, and where can they get a right handed hitter to even acceptably fill the gap Rodriguez would leave.
Given recent years, what is most likely is that with or without Rodriguez, the Yankees will not be a champion team, likely not even a World Series participant. So then the question is: will they be a more exciting, interesting team with him or without him. This seems to answer itself . . . a guy capable of hitting 50+ home runs and driving in way over 100 is exciting, and adding fielding, good average, stolen bases are pluses.
If I ran the Yankees, I would pay what is required, get rid of old pitchers . . . Mussina, Clemens, Petit, go with young, rookie pitchers, try to buy one excellent veteran starter and hope for some gold in the young pitcher crop. They will need that because even with Rodriguez, he will not match what was something of a career year, Giambi, if still on the team, is in bad decline, Posada is older, also had a career year, and catchers tend to go, Jeter is not getting younger, Matsui looked overmatched at times, Cabrera probably played as good as he can, etc. The back up catcher and back up first baseman cannot hit, and Abreu is solid but stolid. Without Rodriguez, they would be relatively punchless, with him they will probably be worse than last year but still good run wise. The one guy who they can really expect to be even better is Cano, who has the makings of a batting champion with power. He has to learn to play the first halves of seasons though.
Paul