3-25-87 Wednesday. Last night’s philosophy of law seminar was frustrating. The subject is voluntariness, and the question was whether one can voluntarily commit an irrational action. A second question is whether one can voluntarily commit an unreasonable action. Now, the answers to these questions depend crucially on how we conceptualize voluntariness, rationality, and reasonableness, and [Joel] Feinberg gives conceptions in his book Harm to Self [1986]. But the students seem to ignore his conceptions and go off the deep end in their arguments. The entire course has been conducted in this manner. If I were Joel, I’d make it clear up front what we’re assuming, and then see what follows logically from it. But perhaps he wants the students to come at the issues from many different directions in order to furnish him with new perspectives and ideas. I made only a couple of comments this evening. Afterward, I argued with David Cortner, Ann Levey, Clark Wolf, and Jonathan Kandell.
Our governor, Evan Mecham, is at it again. First he cancelled [sic; should be “canceled”] the Martin Luther King, Jr, holiday; then he appointed Jim Cooper, a creationist, to a high administration post; then he decreed a Phoenix newspaper columnist a “nonperson”; and now he has infuriated people with a comment about blacks. Mecham said that when he was growing up, the word “pickaninny” was not derogatory to blacks. In fact, he said, he knew black parents who referred to their own children as “pickaninnies.” Black leaders were outraged by this comment, not only because it is likely false that any parent used the term as Mecham says, but because the governor would make it sound so mild. Mecham denies that he is a racist, but every word and action belies it. By now, I think, he has done something to alienate most of the Arizona electorate. Constitutionally, no governor can be recalled from office for six months. I predict that there will be a full-fledged recall campaign this summer, and that Mecham will be ousted. He is an embarrassment to our state and to the nation. [Recall petitions were gathered and a recall election set for May 1988. In the meantime, Mecham was impeached, convicted, and removed from office, so the recall election was canceled.]